That also might have answered my question about the oldest burial in the cemetery...Isabella Moss, 1848.
Actually, the oldest burial date on record was that of William B. Nobles. Here is a snippet of a newspaper article from 1935:
Blue Island Sun-Standard
August 16, 1935
"The earliest date noticed in the cemetery was that on the tombstone of William B. Nobles who died in 1838 at the age of 36. Mr. Fulton says that many of the tombstones were not erected until years after some of the people had died but the Nobles stone is undoubtedly old but probably not as old as the death."
The complete article
can be read here if you are interested.
Then, for fun, if you search the Illinois Public Domain Land Tract Sales database you will find that William owned property next to the cemetery in 1835. The legal description would put it at approximately 143rd and Ridgeland Ave. For a better description, it would be south of 143rd and then east of Ridgeland. And then the southeast corner of the property line would
sort of go near the house foundation with the single well on the north side of the old Midlothian Turnpike. There are, however, records showing Thomas McClintock owning a portion of the property next to the cemetery as well. Thomas purchased the property in the same year as William but it would have been between Williams' property and the house foundation on the north side of the old road. Then there is a
1900s map showing that
James Fullerton owned all the property that both William and Thomas used to own.
Here are a couple of the records:
Purchaser: NOBLE WILLIAM B
Residence of Purchaser: UNKNOWN
Social Status:
Legal Description:
Aliquot Parts or Lot: W2SW
Section Number: 08
Township: 36N
Range: 13E
Meridan: 3
County of Purchase: COOK
Details of Sale:
Acres: 40.00
Price per Acre: 1.25
Total Price: 50.00
Type of Sale: FD
Date of Purchase: 06/26/1835
Volume: 687
Page: 167
-----------------------------------------------
Detailed Information
Purchaser: NOBLE WILLIAM B
Residence of Purchaser: UNKNOWN
Social Status:
Legal Description:
Aliquot Parts or Lot: W2NW
Section Number: 08
Township: 36N
Range: 13E
Meridan: 3
County of Purchase: COOK
Details of Sale:
Acres: 40.00
Price per Acre: 1.25
Total Price: 50.00
Type of Sale: FD
Date of Purchase: 06/26/1835
Volume: 687
Page: 167
Don't pay too much attention to the "Acres" description. He probably only had 40 and not 80 if you combine the records. You come across discrepancies like that all the time. Also, the poor guy dies 3 years after officially purchasing the land... I am actually ordering copies of all the land records in the general area from the state archives. They only let you request two at a time so it will take a while before I get them all. I also found records for the Batchelder family

That will be a fun set of land sales records to have. Plus I may have some more evidence that the Batchelders were here before the Rexfords. As most people know, the Rexfords are the ones that tried to claim Batchelors Grove as their own back in the day by saying it was for a "group of single men." Brad Bettenhausen mentions it in the History section but I found a earlier date to help support the theory!

Once I get the land records and a copy of my other "evidence" I will post them in the Archives over at bachelorsgrove.com